My Aunt Lynn was out shopping at Marc's and bought Laila, her granddaughter, a few Sesame Street toys at $1 each. She ended up with an extra one, an Elmo in fact, and asked if Madeline would like to have it. She warned me that the toy was 18 months+, but we agreed it wasn't a choking hazard and gave her the doll. First mistake.
You see, there were no chokable parts to Elmo, but it was not until she dropped him on the floor at the mall all wet and slobbery when I decided to wash him for the first time that I recognized the need for the age rating. I look at the tag and see the words I would come to despise, "SURFACE WASHABLE ONLY". Why anyone would make a stuffed animal surface washable is beyond me, but it did explain why he was for children 18 months+. We tried to take Elmo away, but our child can talk and wouldn't you know that Elmo is one of her best words. She wakes up asking for him and basically asked for him so much, we realized there was no separating a girl and her Elmo.
In Seattle, Auntie Masha took one look at filthy, stinky old Elmo and decided something must be done. And we embarked on a two-Toys-R-Us trip in search of a perfect replacement: a washable replacement. Low and behold, we found a washable Elmo for 0 months+. Sold. We brought it home to her, she took him in her arms, and chucked him to the side, in favor of old Elmo. To this day, I am not sure she actually realizes "New Elmo" is actually Elmo.
Fast forward. Rami (my college friend) comes over to see Madeline. She brings a gift. Wouldn't you know she picked just the right one. Elmo. That talks. And is 18 months+. Learned that mistake and put him away for safe keeping.
So now we have 3 Elmo's, only one of which Madeline actually plays with. And so, the search is on for a replacement for "Old Elmo". My friend Stephanie from playgroup tells me she just bought her son Jack the exact same Elmo from Target for $4.99. Ok, so it isn't the Marc's price of $1, but definitely worth the upgrade. I head to Target to buy "New Old Elmo". It is love at first sight. "Old Elmo" goes to Grandma's (Madeline calls her Ama) and we are left with "New Old Elmo". Everyone is happy.
Until, as all Elmo's in our house do, he begins to get dirty and stinky. I act swiftly. We go to Target and buy two fresh Elmos. For our purposes here, we will call them "Newer Old Elmo" and "Newest Old Elmo". "Newer Old Elmo" is immediately swapped out for "New Old Elmo". "Old Elmo" gets to go live with Bobbie, "New Old Elmo" with Ama, and "Newest Old Elmo" goes to the hall closet, safe and clean until he is needed.
The moral of this story is three-fold. A) Never give a teething child a toy that isn't machine washable. 2) If you do, it will cost you $20 in replacements. and c) Buy stock in Elmo, I will send your kids to college!


